Choosing the right Integrated Development Environment (IDE) can make all the difference in coding efficiency and productivity.
NetBeans vs IntelliJ is a common debate among developers looking for the best tools to support their Java development projects. Both are powerful, feature-rich options but cater to slightly different needs.
In this article, you’ll get an in-depth comparison of NetBeans and IntelliJ IDEA. We’ll go into key aspects such as performance, code assistance, plugin ecosystems, and user interfaces.
You’ll also learn how each IDE fares in specialized areas like Java server-side development, mobile and Android development, and web and front-end development.
By the end of this read, you’ll have a clearer understanding of which IDE might suit your specific development requirements, guiding you towards a more informed decision.
NetBeans vs IntelliJ
| Feature/Aspect | NetBeans | IntelliJ IDEA |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Apache Software Foundation (originally Sun) | JetBrains |
| License | Open-source, Apache License 2.0 | Community Edition: Open-source, Apache 2.0; Ultimate Edition: Proprietary, Subscription-based |
| Supported Languages | Java, PHP, C/C++, JavaScript, and more | Java, Kotlin, Groovy, Scala, and more via plugins |
| User Interface | Simplistic and flexible | Modern and intuitive with rich features |
| Performance | Can be slower with large projects | Generally faster, particularly in indexing and search operations |
| Plugins | Fewer plugins available | Robust plugin ecosystem with extensive integrations |
| Code Suggestions | Decent IntelliSense | Advanced code suggestions with AI-based features |
| Version Control | Integrated support for Git, Mercurial, Subversion | Excellent integration with VCS, GitHub, and more |
| Refactoring Tools | Standard refactoring tools | Comprehensive refactoring options with smart code assistance |
| Community Support | Good support with a smaller community | Larger community with extensive resources and documentation |
| Customization | Limited customization with basic themes | Highly customizable with numerous themes and plugins |
| Memory Usage | Typically higher memory usage | Optimized memory usage with more control over configurations |
| Deployment Tools | Basic support for application deployment | Advanced deployment tools, Docker and Kubernetes support in Ultimate Edition |
| Enterprise Features | Limited, suitable for smaller projects | Extensive enterprise-level features in the Ultimate edition |
| Learning Curve | Easier for beginners, more straightforward UI | Steeper learning curve due to the abundance of features |
IntelliJ IDEA: Features, Strengths, and Weaknesses
Core Features of IntelliJ IDEA
Paid vs. Free (Community vs. Ultimate Editions)
IntelliJ IDEA comes in two flavors: the free Community Edition and the paid Ultimate Edition.
While the Community Edition provides a solid foundation for basic development, the Ultimate Edition unlocks advanced features aimed at enterprise-level needs and extensive framework support.
Code analysis, refactoring tools, and smart autocompletion
Deep code analysis and intuitive refactoring tools characterize the robustness of IntelliJ IDEA.
The smart autocompletion isn’t just about speed – it’s about accuracy. This IDE seems to understand your code almost as well as you do, guiding you towards cleaner, more efficient writing.
Seamless integration with popular build tools (Maven, Gradle)
When it comes to build tools, IntelliJ IDEA offers seamless integration with industry standards like Maven and Gradle.
This ensures that your build processes are smooth and your dependencies are managed with utmost efficiency.
Strengths of IntelliJ IDEA
Advanced code intelligence and deep understanding of code
IntelliJ IDEA’s advanced code intelligence goes beyond basic syntax highlighting.
It offers profound insights into your codebase, suggesting improvements and identifying potential issues you might overlook.
Feature-rich refactoring options help maintain and improve code quality effortlessly.
Clean, modern user interface and ergonomic design
A clean, modern user interface focuses on user ergonomics. The design minimizes distractions and enhances productivity, allowing for a streamlined development experience.
The layout and organization feel intuitive, reducing the cognitive load on the developer.
Comprehensive multi-language support (Java, Kotlin, Groovy, Scala)
Support for a comprehensive set of languages like Java, Kotlin, Groovy, and Scala ensures that IntelliJ IDEA can accommodate a wide range of development needs.
This flexibility makes it appealing to diverse development teams working across different projects.
Weaknesses of IntelliJ IDEA
Paid Ultimate Edition might be a barrier for some developers
The cost of the Ultimate Edition can be a barrier for some developers, especially those who are freelancers or work within tight budget constraints.
While the Community Edition is free, it lacks some of the advanced features available in the paid version.
Higher resource consumption compared to other IDEs
IntelliJ IDEA is resource-hungry compared to its counterparts.
Running this IDE on older hardware or systems with limited resources can lead to slower performance, potentially affecting development speed and efficiency.
Steeper learning curve for new users
New users might find IntelliJ IDEA’s array of features overwhelming.
There’s a steeper learning curve compared to other IDEs, demanding time and effort to become proficient. This might deter beginners who seek a more straightforward tool to start with.
IDE: Features, Strengths, and Weaknesses
Core Features of NetBeans
Free and open-source under the Apache Software Foundation
NetBeans is freely available, open-source, and backed by the Apache Software Foundation.
This robust support ensures continuous improvements, security updates, and a reliable platform for coding needs without any cost barriers.
Support for JavaFX, Java EE, and web development
NetBeans shines with its built-in support for JavaFX, Java EE, and web development.
Whether you’re creating desktop applications or web-based solutions, it has the tools you need right out of the box.
Modular structure with support for multiple languages (Java, PHP, C++)
Flexible and modular, NetBeans supports multiple programming languages like Java, PHP, and C++.
This adaptability ensures developers can pivot between different languages and projects without switching IDEs.
Strengths of NetBeans
Beginner-friendly interface and straightforward navigation
The interface is designed with newcomers in mind. Easy to navigate and intuitive, NetBeans reduces the learning curve, making it accessible to beginners while still being powerful enough for seasoned developers.
Strong support for JavaFX and integration with Java 8 features
Java developers will appreciate the strong support for JavaFX and seamless integration with Java 8 features.
This allows for building modern, interactive applications using the latest Java capabilities effectively.
Excellent built-in tools for refactoring and code analysis
NetBeans includes built-in tools that excel at refactoring and code analysis.
These tools help maintain code quality and streamline the development process by making it easier to catch potential issues early on.
Weaknesses of NetBeans
Fewer plugins compared to IntelliJ IDEA
Limited customization options
When it comes to customization, NetBeans doesn’t offer as many options as its competitors. Developers who prefer to tailor their IDE in detail might find this limiting, as the available configurations are fewer and less flexible.
Uncertain future development trajectory due to Apache governance
The trajectory of its development can feel uncertain. Apache governance ensures stability but sometimes slows down rapid innovation, raising concerns about the future updates and feature additions in comparison to other IDEs.
Key Comparisons: IntelliJ IDEA, and NetBeans
Performance and Resource Management
Speed and efficiency on different hardware setups
IntelliJ IDEA, on the other hand, is resource-intensive. While it offers advanced features, it demands modern hardware for smooth operation.
NetBeans falls somewhere in between, generally performing adequately on most systems without being too resource-hungry.
Handling of large projects and memory consumption
IntelliJ IDEA, known for its intelligent features, can handle large projects with ease but at the cost of higher memory usage.
NetBeans performs efficiently even with sizeable projects, balancing resource use well but offering fewer sophisticated tools.
Code Assistance and Refactoring Tools
IntelliJ IDEA’s advanced refactoring and code insight capabilities
IntelliJ IDEA excels with its advanced refactoring tools and deep code insight.
The software understands your code structure, offering precise refactoring options that significantly improve productivity and code quality.
NetBeans’ Inspect & Transform and built-in support for Java 8
NetBeans includes Inspect & Transform, a powerful feature for code refactoring.
Combined with its built-in support for Java 8, it makes code analysis and transformation straightforward and effective, especially for Java-focused projects.
Plugin Ecosystems and Customization
IntelliJ’s marketplace for plugins and built-in functionality
IntelliJ has a well-organized marketplace for plugins, with many built-in functionalities reducing the need for external extensions. The curated selection ensures smoother operation, though it’s less extensive compared to Eclipse.
NetBeans’ more limited but stable plugin offerings
NetBeans has fewer plugins compared to Eclipse and IntelliJ. However, the limited number ensures greater stability and fewer compatibility issues, making it a solid choice for those who prefer reliability over extensive customization.
User Interface and Developer Ergonomics
IntelliJ IDEA’s focus on minimizing distractions and enhancing flow
IntelliJ IDEA focuses on minimizing distractions through a clean and modern user interface.
Its ergonomic design enhances developer flow, reducing the time spent navigating the IDE and increasing productivity.
NetBeans’ simplicity and accessibility for new developers
NetBeans shines with its simplicity and straightforward navigation, making it accessible for new developers.
While it may not offer the extensive customizability of Eclipse or the advanced features of IntelliJ IDEA, its user-friendly design makes it an attractive choice for beginners.
Specialized Usage: Tailoring Each IDE to Specific Developer Needs
Java Server-Side Development
NetBeans’ integration with Java EE and support for Maven projects
NetBeans excels with its seamless integration of Java EE, making enterprise development smoother. The support for Maven projects means dependency management and project builds are straightforward, cutting down setup time significantly.
IntelliJ IDEA’s Ultimate Edition for enterprise development
For those diving deep into enterprise-level development, IntelliJ IDEA’s Ultimate Edition is packed with power. Full Java EE support, advanced debugging tools, and features tailored for complex projects elevate it above others.
Mobile and Android Development
IntelliJ IDEA’s connection to Android Studio and Android development
IntelliJ IDEA boasts a close connection with Android Studio, offering a smooth transition for Android development.
It integrates the Android SDK, making setup for mobile projects efficient and developer-friendly.
NetBeans’ limited support for mobile development
NetBeans doesn’t quite hold up in the mobile arena.
Limited support for Android and mobile development keeps it in the shadows compared to its counterparts, lacking the extensive tools and ecosystem needed for robust mobile app creation.
Web and Front-End Development
IntelliJ IDEA’s support for modern web frameworks (React, Angular, etc.)
IntelliJ IDEA is a powerhouse for web and front-end development.
With first-class support for frameworks like React, Angular, and Vue.js, it offers robust tools for modern web application development, complete with smart autocompletion and powerful debugging options.
NetBeans’ native support for HTML5, CSS, and JavaScript
NetBeans stands strong with native support for HTML5, CSS, and JavaScript.
This built-in functionality makes it a reliable choice for straightforward web development tasks, from designing sleek UIs to coding dynamic web interfaces.
Project Setup, Compilation, and Build Tools
Project Import and Setup
Importing projects into IntelliJ IDEA from NetBeans and Eclipse
Importing projects can be a breeze, or a headache, depending on the IDE. IntelliJ IDEA simplifies the process.
Whether you’re shifting from NetBeans or Eclipse, the import functionality ensures a smooth transition. It respects your existing project structure, reducing the hassles of setup.
Build Tools Integration
IntelliJ IDEA’s full integration with Maven and Gradle
Build tools are the backbone of serious development work. IntelliJ IDEA shines here, offering full integration with both Maven and Gradle.
It smoothly manages dependencies, ensuring that your builds are consistent and repeatable.
NetBeans’ graphical dependency management for Maven projects
For those who prefer a visual approach, NetBeans delivers with its graphical dependency management for Maven projects.
The interface makes handling dependencies more intuitive, reducing the complexity typically associated with build configurations.
Compilation and Deployment Automation
IntelliJ’s automated code saving and deployment options
Automation in IntelliJ IDEA extends to code saving and deployment. It allows for automatic code saves, streamlining the deployment process. This feature ensures that your latest changes are always part of the deployment, minimizing manual intervention.
NetBeans’ Compile-on-Save feature for quicker deployments
NetBeans also offers automation, with the Compile-on-Save feature. This ensures that as you code, the changes are compiled in real-time, leading to faster deployments and a more seamless development experience all around.
Version Control and Collaboration Features
Version Control Integration
IntelliJ IDEA’s seamless integration with Git, Mercurial, and Subversion
Version control is essential. IntelliJ IDEA handles it cleanly, integrating smoothly with Git, Mercurial, and Subversion. No extra configuration hurdles. It’s all right there, making it simple to manage branches, commits, and merges.
NetBeans’ integrated support for Git and SVN
NetBeans keeps it straightforward with integrated support for Git and SVN. The built-in tools handle version control without needing extensive setup, ideal for developers who value simplicity and efficiency.
Team Collaboration and Project Sharing
IntelliJ’s XML-based run/debug configurations and sharing options
When it comes to collaboration, IntelliJ excels with XML-based run/debug configurations. These can be shared across teams effortlessly, ensuring everyone’s on the same page, literally. It’s a small feature that makes a big difference in larger teams.
NetBeans’ native support for version-controlled projects
NetBeans brings native support for version-controlled projects, streamlining collaboration. Developers can work on the same project, with version control seamlessly integrated, making it easy to manage code changes and synchronize efforts across the team.
FAQ On NetBeans vs IntelliJ
What is the main feature of IntelliJ IDEA that makes it stand out?
IntelliJ IDEA’s code intelligence is unmatched. The IDE offers smart autocompletion, deep code understanding, and advanced refactoring tools. It predicts what you need next, enhancing productivity and code quality.
Is NetBeans free to use?
Yes, NetBeans is completely free and open-source. Maintained by the Apache Software Foundation, it provides robust features without any licensing costs, making it accessible for everyone from beginners to seasoned developers.
Does IntelliJ IDEA support multiple programming languages?
Absolutely, IntelliJ IDEA supports multiple languages. Though known for Java, it also excels with Kotlin, Groovy, and Scala. This flexibility makes it a versatile tool for various programming tasks.
How does NetBeans handle JavaFX and Java EE projects?
NetBeans offers strong support for JavaFX and Java EE. It seamlessly integrates these frameworks, allowing for smooth development of both desktop and enterprise-level applications within a single environment.
Are there any performance concerns with IntelliJ IDEA?
IntelliJ IDEA is resource-intensive. It requires modern hardware for optimal performance. While it provides a plethora of features, older systems might experience slower performance, impacting productivity.
What makes NetBeans beginner-friendly?
NetBeans’ intuitive interface and straightforward navigation are highlights. It reduces the learning curve, making it ideal for beginners who need a robust yet easy-to-use development environment.
What are the most notable plugins available for NetBeans?
NetBeans has fewer plugins compared to its counterparts, yet the available ones are reliable. Notable plugins include those for JavaFX, C++, and PHP development, enhancing its core functionality.
How does IntelliJ IDEA support collaboration among team members?
IntelliJ IDEA features XML-based run/debug configurations that can be easily shared. It supports team collaboration, making it easier to synchronize efforts and streamline project workflows.
What are the deployment options like in NetBeans?
NetBeans offers Compile-on-Save, allowing quicker deployment. This feature ensures real-time changes are compiled immediately, reducing the steps needed to deploy updates, which speeds up the development process.
Conclusion
NetBeans vs IntelliJ is a crucial decision for developers seeking the best IDE for their coding needs. Both options are powerful but cater to different preferences and requirements.
NetBeans is free and open-source with robust JavaFX and Java EE support. It’s beginner-friendly, thanks to its intuitive interface and straightforward navigation. Its Compile-on-Save feature facilitates quicker deployments, making it user-efficient.
On the other hand, IntelliJ IDEA stands out with its exceptional code intelligence and comprehensive multi-language support. It integrates seamlessly with build tools like Maven and Gradle, and its advanced refactoring capabilities elevate coding practices. Despite its resource-intensive nature, the smart autocompletion and deep understanding of code enhance productivity.
In conclusion, choosing between NetBeans and IntelliJ IDEA boils down to specific development needs. Understanding the strengths and applying them to your projects ensures an optimal coding environment.
With over a decade in the tech field, Bogdan blends technical expertise with insights on business innovation in technology.
A regular contributor to TMS Outsource's blog, where you'll find sharp analyses on software development, tech business strategies, and global tech dynamics.
- What Is Git Bash? A Beginner’s Guide to Using It - March 20, 2025
- Can You Find Out How Big Your Digital Footprint is? - March 20, 2025
- What Does Git Stash Do? Save and Restore Changes - March 19, 2025
